A Pennsylvania couple is suing the previous owner of their dream stone cottage, claiming that hidden Nazi symbols embedded in the floor tiles have made the home so offensive they cannot live there. Daniel and Lynne Rae Wentworth bought the five-bedroom property in Beaver for $500,000 in 2023, instantly captivated by its rustic charm and serene riverside setting.
Shocking discovery shatters homeownership joy
The Wentworths fell in love with the cottage's exposed stone walls, vaulted ceilings and lush surroundings when they purchased it from an 85-year-old German immigrant who had owned it for nearly 50 years. Their excitement turned to horror months later during routine renovations, when they noticed faint swastika patterns etched into the slate floor tiles throughout the main living areas and kitchen. "We thought it was a stunning forever home," Lynne Rae said, "but uncovering Nazi symbols felt like a violation – we can't unsee them underfoot every day."
Experts confirmed the tiles, imported decades ago, bear subtle Third Reich iconography disguised within geometric designs, invisible to casual glances but unmistakable upon close inspection.
Lawsuit demands full refund and damages
The couple filed suit in Beaver County Court, alleging fraud and failure to disclose material defects, seeking their $500k purchase price back plus relocation costs, emotional distress compensation and legal fees. They argue the symbols constitute a "stigmatizing defect" that destroys the property's marketability, especially in a diverse community sensitive to Holocaust history. Court documents reveal the seller knew of the tiles' origins, having installed them himself in the 1970s from surplus European stock.
Neighbors expressed shock, with one calling it "a chilling reminder of unchecked pasts."
German owner's silence fuels outrage
The elderly ex-owner, identified only as "Herr M" in filings, has not commented publicly, but his attorney claims the symbols were "artistic flourishes" common in vintage European flooring, not intentional propaganda. Records show he fled Germany as a teen in 1945, but plaintiffs' investigators uncovered family ties to wartime service, raising questions about why such tiles ended up in an American home. The cottage now sits vacant, listed quietly for resale at a discount while the case awaits a hearing.
Real estate lawyers note Pennsylvania's "as-is" sales clauses offer limited protection against undisclosed historical horrors, predicting a tough battle over intent versus ignorance. For the Wentworths, the stone dream cottage has become an unlivable symbol of betrayal.
Comments
Post a Comment