.
As heir apparent, Tamim
has led on the implementation of Vision 2030, Qatar's ambitious national
strategy which sets out to promote "justice, benevolence and equality."
He is also the author of the country's current five-year plan, in which
he calls for "continuous modernization and development of public
institutions."
The key question now is
whether these finely crafted state strategy documents Tamim has authored
as heir apparent can translate into real human rights change in Qatar's
institutions, as the rubber hits the road and he takes control of
government.
The current five-year
strategy, for example, promises that there will be much-needed laws to
criminalise domestic violence and to give labour rights to migrant
domestic workers, something for which campaigners have been calling for
years. The strategy leaves no room for disagreement when it says that
"since 2004 Qatar has seen a significant jump in the number of reported
domestic violence incidents against women and children."
James Lynch
But when Amnesty
International met government officials in Doha earlier this year, they
played down incidents of domestic violence as merely "individual cases".
And a senior Labour Ministry official recently told a Qatari newspaper
that "there is no need for a law for housemaids... Since there is a
contract signed between a maid and her employer, a law isn't needed."
Vision 2030 also says it
embodies the principles of the country's constitution which "protects
public and personal freedoms". And yet there was widespread shock last
November, when a court in Doha sentenced a Qatari poet, Mohammed al-Ajami, to life imprisonment on charges of incitement "to overthrow the ruling system", and "insulting the Amir."
The charges relate to a
2010 poem criticizing the ruling family, but activists believed that the
real reason for his arrest was his 2011 "Jasmine Poem" which read: "we
are all Tunisia in the face of the repressive elite." All the
information available points to al-Ajami being placed behind bars solely
for his words.
At the time one regional
activist told Amnesty that "we expected better," referring to Qatar's
efforts to paint itself as a country promoting freedom of expression, as
host to both the Al Jazeera network and the Doha Center for Media
Freedom.
Disturbingly, almost at
the same time, the authorities moved to tighten control on freedom of
expression with a new draft media law, which, if approved, would require
all publications to be approved by a government-appointed "competent
authority" empowered to remove content or prevent printing.
Al-Ajami's sentence was
reduced to 15 years in February, which has done little to quell the
outrage. The treatment of his case will be an early signal of whether
Qatar's new ruler intends to allow greater freedoms of expression at
home
.
Tamim has also chaired
the committee organizing the Qatar 2022 World Cup, the country's most
ambitious global initiative yet. It is a sensitive project and one that
will test the new ruler's commitment to real reform.
Since Qatar won the
right to host the tournament, the country has come under intense
scrutiny for its treatment of migrant construction workers, who come
primarily from South Asia.
There are fears that the
hundreds of thousands of new workers who will be needed to build the
stadiums and infrastructure for the World Cup could face exploitation or
even forced labor.
Amnesty International
has been interviewing migrant laborers and construction companies in
Qatar over the past nine months, and has found that the abuse of migrant
laborers runs deep, with some workers on major national projects going
for months without being paid, being prevented from leaving the country
by their employers and even struggling to afford food
.
The challenge for the
World Cup Committee is how to ensure that the companies they employ to
build their projects comply with international labor standards.
Of course, it cannot be
only about the organizing committee. The role of the government to
prevent entrenched exploitation will be critical. Tamim's five-year plan
recognizes -- with slightly surprising candor -- that "improving labor
rights will not only benefit employees but will also enhance Qatar's
global image as a leading and progressive nation
."
But Qatar's new ruler
will need to be aware that the opposite will also be true. Unless his
government is able to energetically enforce labor protections and make
major reforms to the repressive Sponsorship Law which gives employers
excessive powers over their workers, Qatar's global image will
inevitably suffer, just as the migrant workers Amnesty International has
met are suffering right now.
Sheikh Tamim and his
ministers will need to show political will if they want to deliver the
freedom and justice called for in the state strategy set under his
stewardship. Activists, across the region and globally, will be watching
carefully for early signs of that will.
Comments
Post a Comment